Sarah 4th Dec 2025

Goes on Beautifully

I haven't worn anything on my eyes for ages due to nothing being "natural". I bought this eyeliner and I feel like I don't need to worry.

Laurie 20th Sep 2025

Eye Liner

very happy with the envy eyeliner.

Diana 18th Sep 2025

Love it

Love the color

Bonnie 3rd Sep 2025

eye liner

As a woman of a certain age, and with tender skin, I appreciate the eye liner that glides on smoothly and leaves a nice line. I am tired of other name brands cosmetics that almost tear your skin to get a liner to work. I have used Cover Girl for 50 years, never really satisfied with the product. I am so happy to upgrade and use honeybee products. I even bought some eye shadow to try out! Thank You,!

Christie 29th Jul 2025

mascara

Honeybee gardens product was recommended to me recently while on vacation. A unique apothecary shop I visited carried their line. I like the applicator wand; it does not cause too much clumping. My eyes can be sensitive to certain make-up, but I have not experienced any issues since using this product. I have been using their mascara a little over 6 weeks.

Irene Hardin 26th Jul 2025

Great product

Very soft and easy to apply.

Heather 15th Jul 2025

Eyeliner

I got Jet black and Envy. They go on very nicely but they do smudge quite easily and quickly.

LynnAnn Thomas 15th Jul 2025

Perfect for my mature eyes!

I'm 75 and stopped wearing pencil eyeliner years ago when my eye lids became saggy and crinkled. I saw a demo video for Honey Bee Gardens pencil eye shadow on Instagram and thought....what the heck? It's amazing. I almost don't have to press down to get a really nice line. It doesn't pull my skin along as I barely have to skim along my eyelash line. I haven't had to sharpen it yet so hopefully will not crumble in the sharpener. Anyway, I highly recommend it for those of us who are OLD BUT NOT ELDERLY!!

Mimi 13th Jul 2025

A lovely little pencil at a lovely little price!

Very happy with this pencil. Goes on smoothly. Stays in place. Perfect shade of green with my brown eyes. Thank you!

Karen Neumann 5th Jun 2025

Extraordinary Eyeliner!

I learned recently that most makeup is full of toxic garbage! I wanted to use clean ingredients on my face! I tried a few, with no luck. Stumbled across Honeybee Gardens and thought I’d give them a try! Best thing I ever “stumbled” over … cuz now I’ve “fallen” for this company!!! This eyeliner is great. I’m a seasoned 60-yr. old (non-pro! Pretty amateur-ish to be honest!!) and this eyeliner works great with my … ahem … “mature” skin! Goes on smooth with no tugging and lasts! Love it!

Kara 7th Apr 2025

Best eye pencil

Finding a great eye liner is hard. But I love this eye pencil! It doesn’t scratch my eyelid when applying and it goes on super smooth. A great price as well!

Julie 13th Mar 2025

Effortless eyeliner

This is my absolute favorite eyeliner. It glides on so smoothly without tugging the skin yet it holds up all day.

Laura Zirzow 6th Feb 2025

effortless eyeliner

I haven't been using these long, but they are great. Lots of colors to choose from and it stays on and looks good all day.

Essie 15th Jan 2025

Eye liner

Love this eyeliner! It's a soft texture that glides easily and doesn't irritate my eyes. I have used the purple liner and it is a deep purple that is subtle and accentuates the eyes really well. After a few hours the liner melts into a natural, soft look.

Laura Zirzow 6th Jan 2025

effortless eyeliner

I love these liners. The colors are wonderful and these liners go on easy.

S 26th Dec 2024

Pretty eyeliner pencil

The colors are pretty and easy to use.

Julie 14th Dec 2024

Truly "Effortless"

This eyeliner pencil glides on more smoothly than any other pencil I've ever tried. Finally, a brown eyeliner (Belgian Chocolate) that is a deep, rich brown, not pale cocoa! It wears all day, doesn't irritate my super sensitive skin, and is easily removed with a drop of oil - no rubbing required.

Karen 9th Dec 2024

Eye Liner - so smooth

Love this eyeliner - goes on so smooth and its all natural!

Laurie 9th Dec 2024

Eye Liner

I have used this Eye liner for several years and never strayed back to the other brands I have used. Smooth and easy to use, even on older eyes! Highly recommend the ease of applying and it stays and stays and stays. Even through times of tears recently, just patting the tears... the eye liner stayed. AWESOME!!!

Julie Larkin 1st Jul 2024

Nice eye liner!

Smooth application and stays put, thank you : )

Tammy 7th Jun 2024

Eye liner

I have been looking for years for a product that would not burn my eyes!! Thank you thank you thank you I HAVE FINALLY FOUND IT!! I love the color - makes my green eyes pop! I love it! Thank you so much for a great product!!

Sandy 19th May 2024

Eyeliner

Love this eyeliner!

Gwyn 8th Jan 2024

Best eyeliner ever!

I have used this eyeliner for a few years now and will never use anything else! I love that I’m not putting harmful chemicals on my eyes. It glides on easily and lasts all day. I recommend getting the sharpener also. It works so well, I ordered a couple more for my daughter and travel bag.

Karen 25th Dec 2023

Wonderful Eyeliner

This eyeliner pencil is so smooth and silky, only a very light touch is needed when applying. One of the better pencils that I ever used

Karen 2nd Oct 2023

Eyeliner - Envy

Love this eyeliner. Longtime Aveda user and as you know they discontinued makeup. I think I like this one better! It goes on smoothly and stays on.

Katherine Phillips 1st May 2023

eye shadow

Love all your products!!!

Elaine Mason 28th Apr 2023

Effortless Eyeliner

I love these because they don't drag or pull and are truly effortless. I have one in almost every color and they sharpen well.

Holly Santa 9th Mar 2023

Eye liner

Excellent product. Love it !

Louanne 19th Feb 2023

effortless eye liner

Perfect! Nice darl brown color -- not too harsh. It goes on smoothly, doesn't smear, and best of all, doesn't make my eyes itch. I have tried a lot of organic and natural products but this is the best for me.

Arlene Suarez 9th Feb 2023

Eye liner

Wow, wow!! I love this eyeliner. Goes on smoothly and lasts with minimal smearing, which is very common for me. Illi love that these products are all-natural.

Valerie 26th Jan 2023

could be good

Smooth application and decently long wear. If it were easier to sharpen and came in a broader range of colors, I'd rate it higher. Belgian Chocolate is too close to black--I'd love a softer brown. And the pencil is difficult to sharpen to a narrow point.

Terri 8th Jan 2023

Eye liner

It goes on like silk , luv it

Lacey 7th Jan 2023

Great Eyeliner

I have this eyeliner in black, brown (Belgian Chocolate) and blue. It goes on smoothly with rich deep color, has great staying power, and doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes. Great product for a great price!

Jan 10th Nov 2022

Truly effortless

Easy to apply - can be as subtle or as dramatic as you like. Great for smudging into a soft accent to go with your Bellissima mascara. And gentle for sensitive eyelids.

Judy Helton 7th Sep 2022

Effortless Eyeliner

I like this eyeliner very much. It is soft and easy to apply, yet it wears well. The latest I ordered was Blue Jeans, but I have it in Envy, Belgian Chocolate and Smoking gun. All the colors have the same great quality.

Mary Kane 5th Jun 2022

Passion eye liner

Like the color goes on smoothly. Will keep buying this eye liner

Christine Manter 16th May 2022

Bluejeans eyeliner

I love this eyeliner!It stays on and looks pretty blue!I have been using for many years and just love this and many other honey bee products!Thanks for all the clean ingredients and wonderful products Honeybee crew!!!!God Bless Us Everyone!

Yvonne 5th May 2022

Aptly Named "Effortless Eyeliner"

This is my Go-To eyeliner. It goes on smooth, the color stays put, and I have no problems sharpening the pencils. My favorites are Belgian Chocolate, Passion, and Envy.

Iris 1st May 2022

buttery smooth

Description says, "This smooth formula won't drag or pull delicate skin. Glides on gently and fluidly from the moment you open it." Can confirm!!! Very impressed with how easily the color went on - NO TUGGING AT ALL!

Dacia 9th Apr 2022

Too soft to sharpen, and product not centered in the wood

I liked this eyeliner (although it's not budge-proof by any means), and used it mostly to smudge under my lower lashes. However, I was unable to sharpen it, as the product is extremely soft at room temperature, and in my case the product was not centered in the wood, leaving a spike of wood all the way to the top (since you will not get a sharp point). Terrific mess trying (two sharpeners tried), and in the end I snapped what was left of the pencil in half and consoled myself that I will get some well-loved OG liner from the drugstore to replace this. In hindsight I might have tried freezing it first for sharpening. Your mileage may vary! RESPONSE: I'm sorry to hear you had issues sharpening the eye liner. Our pencil is a bit softer than some, which makes it tug and pull less on delicate skin around the eyes. We do offer sharpening tips on the product page. Thanks for trying the product.

suzi 17th Mar 2022

eyeliner lover

your eye pencils are fabulous! I love them. Thanks!

Melissa R 12th Mar 2022

Brown Sugar is Redhead approved

I left a review already for one color but i just got in a limited DC color, Brown Sugar, and felt i needed to write one for this color specifically. I can see why not many liked this shade because its a light neutral slightly warm brown, like a coffee with creamer in it. Its a PERFECT color for my brows though. I have natural light auburn/dark strawberry blonde hair and this shade is what ive been searching for for years. Most colors are burgundy, too red, too dark, too brown, too ashy or warm, etc but this one is spot on. Please consider bringing it back as a brow pencil or in the liner section. I wish i would have gotten a second pencil.

Jeanne 10th Feb 2022

My favorite eye liner

I have been using this eye liner for years. It is creamy and applies easily. It’s easy to sharpen and easy to remove. It also lasts a long time. I will continue to purchase when I am running low.

Meredith 10th Feb 2022

Effortless Eyeliner in Ink (black)

I love this eyeliner - I've been using it for at least three years straight. It is a nice bold black, it goes on easily without tugging, it's easy to smudge but stays in place reasonably well, it's easy to build, and it doesn't irritate my eyes at all.

Melissa 4th Feb 2022

Passion

This is such a perfect color, i can see cool and warm tones being able to use this. It didnt irritate my eyes like most other liners do and i can smudge it out to look smokey or to not look harsh. I plan on replacing all my liners with this brand as i go. The only thing is i wish there was a warmer brown option still or a bronze, doesnt even have to have shimmer. Athough shimmer is a nice option as well.

Amanda 21st Dec 2021

Great eyeliner

I love the texture and the colors! It's just great eyeliner.

Kimberly Barrett 13th Nov 2021

Highly recommend!!

Love the color! Goes on beautifully.

Rev. Deborah Beach Giordano 9th Oct 2021

Smooth, easy application, consistent color

Smooth application, good color, can be smudged (in a good way) to create a softer line. Terrific as it does NOT make my eyes water or turn red, as do the products of "other" cosmetic companies. ;-)

Kathy 17th Sep 2021

Effortless Eye Liner

Effortless Eye Liner goes on easily - fades a bit during the day.

Shan 14th Sep 2021

Great eyeliner

These pencils glide on smooth with a creamy finish. Does smudge a bit on eye lids when warm. But stays on fairly well

Susan 9th Sep 2021

No Staying Power

I bought this eyeliner in smoking gun, a metal-grey with silver microglitter. The formula didn't irritate my eyes, but it also didn't apply smoothly and it had zero staying power. Disappointing.

Lise 5th Aug 2021

Eyeliner

I have been using this eyeliner in various colors for several years and they're the best! They go on so smoothly and an also be a base for a powder eye color which really helps all of it to stay on longer. I tend to get allergic reactions to eye make up and have had no trouble with this brand at all!

Elaine Bennett 29th Jul 2021

LOVE!!

Have been using these eyeliners for the past couple of years and LOVE them! No reason to go anywhere else. They apply easily and stay put all day!

Lorene Holderfield 17th May 2021

My Only Eyeliners

I bought both the Jet Black and Belgian Chocolate eyeliners, and I must say I highly recommend HG's eyeliners (and other products). These eyeliners go on smoothly, they stay put, they do not smudge, there are great color options to suit your eye color and/or eyeshadows, and they look great with whatever eyeshadow I pair the eyeliner with. The best part is knowing that these are made with all-natural ingredients and handmade. I can rest easy and relax knowing I am putting good, real, organic stuff on me and not any of that crappy fake, toxic stuff that plagues the stores and beauty industry! I recommend Honeybee Gardens!

Becky Michael 19th Apr 2021

Belgian chocolate eye liner

I am not at all happy with this eyeliner. It is way too dark. I am hoping I will be able to return it and choose a lighter color.

Gina Bird 12th Apr 2021

Passion

I have used HBG eyeliner for years! It goes on smooth like a liquid liner, stays on all day and it's even waterproof!

Amanda 20th Jan 2021

Eye Liner

LOVE this eye liner. It's soft, long wearing, doesn't smudge, and overall AWESOME! Been wearing it for years!

Heather 26th Dec 2020

Great eyeliner

This is so much easier to apply than other eyeliner pencils I have tried. It goes on much more smoothly!

Nicole 8th Dec 2020

Love this!

I LOVE this eyeliner! It really is "effortless." I have used this eyeliner in Envy on and off for a few years now and will never go back to another eyeliner. It glides on smoothly and the rich color is a perfect finishing touch to my eye makeup. Great product that I will continue to buy again and again!

JJ 2nd Dec 2020

Great all-natural eye pencil

This works great as both an eye liner an eyebrow filler! Love that it’s both cruelty free, and all natural!

Jackie Jones 30th Nov 2020

Creamy

Creamy and easy to apply even for those of us that lack skill.

Donna 17th Nov 2020

Effortless eyeliner

I adore this eyeliner! I've been changing over my conventional makeup to organic makeup. The colors are deep (just like I love them to be) stay pretty well and make me feel good about changing over. Makeup should make you feel good as well as look good. That's exactly what organic makeup does and it makes me happy! Customer service is great and shipping is really fast. I'll definitely be purchasing again. Many thanks for your beautiful and affordable products!

Debra 3rd Nov 2020

Perfect Pencil

I had to order more Perfect Pencils in every color because my daughter swiped mine when I wasn't looking! They come in great colors and apply smoothly with no tugging. I only wish there was amethyst color. Thanks Honeybee Gardens for making a great eye pencil!

Jackie 1st Oct 2020

Eyeliner

I have been trying to go all natural with my makeup so I was glad to find these. I have tried two colors (chocolate brown and burgundy) and I really like them. They glide on so softly and are easy to use. These are now my go to eyeliners!

kathy 21st Aug 2020

effortless eyeliner

Love this! I ordered this with hopes of replacing my liquid eyeliner....goes on smoothly...tip is soft and easy to apply

Emily Miller 17th Jul 2020

collecting them all

my only bother is that they don't have more colours. I was recently diagnosed gluten sensitive. Someone told me to switch to GF make up and low and behold this stays on my face all day. No tearing no pain. It is also super duper easy to use. I am in love.

Carrie 11th Jul 2020

Wish it worked for me

I received the beautiful blue liner in the winter collection. I’m glad that everyone loves it, but sadly, the formula smears like crazy on me, even with primer.

Jeanne 28th May 2020

Effortless eyeliner

I love this eyeliner and have been using it for years. It goes on effortlessly and smoothly. It sharpens well and lasts a really long time. It is a great value. The eyeliner lasts all day, but is easy to remove. I have only used Passion, which is a plum/gray color (not overly purple if you are worried about that). The company is reputable and uses quality ingredients. Someone mentioned being frustrated with the packaging. It's completely covered in a plastic coating. I didn't have a problem with mine. Mine had a perforated line that ran the entire length of the eyeliner and peeled right off.

Halyna Barannik 23rd May 2020

eye liner

Your eye liners are the best I have every used, which is why I ordered them in both passion (purple) and belgian chocolate (dark brown). My only objection is to the very tight wrapping that took me tremendous effort to finally peel off.

C. Cummins 19th May 2020

Eyeliner and Mascara

I have used Honeybee Gardens' eyeliner and mascara for a few years now. It means a lot to me to have these organic products. They are a good quality and long-lasting product.

Stephanie 13th Apr 2020

Smooth eyeliner

This is great eyeliner. It glides on easily and looks great until you take it off, and it comes of easily.

Racheal Bowlen 28th Mar 2020

Brown sugar pencil

Nice,nice color. I purchased it particularly for my eyebrows..I thought it may be a little light.but it's pretty and glides on smoothly. I am impressed. Thanks again Honeybees!!!

Elaine 7th Feb 2020

LOVE!

This was a new eye liner color for me - I typically use the Belgian Chocolate which is my everyday go to, but I wanted something different and this fits the bill beautifully!

Donna 3rd Feb 2020

Perfect Pencil

I’ve been a black eye liner girl for decades andthis is far and away the best ever. Smooth application and no raccoon eyes by mid day. I love that the product is thoughtfully made for user and the environment.

Sherrill Fuller 2nd Feb 2020

Stays on

Stays on and doesn't bother my eyes! Love it!

Candace 28th Jan 2020

A favorite!

Honeybee Gardens eyeliner pencils are among my favorite items in my collection! They glide on so smoothly and last all day!

Jen 7th Jan 2020

Best pencil eyeliner!

The efforflesh eyeliner is just that, EFFORTLESS! it glides on smoothly and lasts all day. I use the color passion everyday and have gotten several compliments on the color and how awesome that I make color eyeliner work as an everyday look. I have met black for special occasions, but cannot leave the house without a little passion on my eyes!

Christine 5th Jan 2020

Awesome

I just love this eye liner!I have used before only blue and this one is black!I love them both!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Lisa 2nd Jan 2020

Love this product!

I have used these eyeliners for over a year now and love every one I've tried. They glide easily, sharpen well and they last much longer than other eyeliners in higher price brackets that I've tried. They look great without containing irritating ingredients of other brands. So grateful for this brand and this product!

Sara Parrilli 14th Dec 2019

Non-Irritating!!

Smooth, creamy, non-irritating! I tried the Jet Set, Smoking Gun, and Passion. Love them all and like having some variety for mixing with different eye shadows.

Stephanie Schaider 13th Dec 2019

Wonderful eye liner!

I have tried two of the eye liner colors so far. They go on super smoothly and wear extremely well. They are also easy to take off. Beautiful colors, too.

11th Dec 2019

New favorite eye liner

This eye liner is creamy, easy to blend, and doesn't irritate my eyes. HIGHLY recommend! I purchased it in "Envy" (dark green) and will be purchasing more colors.

Maggie 9th Dec 2019

Very light brown sugar

This is a very light brown on the warm side and I love it. I don’t use dark eyeliners under my bottom lashes so this works for me. It just gives a sheer light golden brown for that monochromatic nude look. I’m fair tone, so it’s the perfect amount of pigment I’m looking for. It’s a natural & clean eyeliner; thank you Honeybee!

armande gil 9th Dec 2019

Excellent eye liner

I have bought 4 of Honeybee eye liner and I love them. they are smooth and apply easily. The colors look great.

13th Nov 2019

Only eyeliner I use!

I love the eyeliner pencil. I don’t have time (or patience) to deal with a mineral eyeliner daily. This pencil eyeliner is easy to use, has great color, and stays put (even during the summer months.). Love it!

Stephanie Schaider 21st Oct 2019

Great eye pencil

Love the eye pencil, looked great all day!

Charly 21st Oct 2019

Awesome!

I have been using this eyeliner for years, it goes on so smooth & lasts all day. Love it!!

Britney Adams 20th Oct 2019

Love this

I’ll start by saying Eyeliner is my must have at all time makeup item. So I’m super picky on how they last and go on. This eyeliner is amazing I had my doubts because other natural eyeliners that I’ve used you really had to push and go over several times to actually make it show up. This says it all in its description it is totally effortless. It basically glides on AND it honestly lasts all day long. I will never purchase another brand!

Debbie 14th Oct 2019

Perfect Pencil

This pencil is exactly what I was looking for, natural, affordable and easy on the eye area in a good range of colors! It really does effortlessly glide onto the eye. I bought it in Passion (smokey plum). I intend to get this in all the colors available! And if Honeybee Gardens decides to make it in more colors, that will be even better!

Laura 7th Oct 2019

Dark Brown, Smooth, Sharpens Easily

Honeybee has the best eyeliner pencil. Others, more expensive organic types, they didn't sharpen well, and they didn't come in dark brown, and they didn't apply in the smooth way that yours does. Thank you for ethically sound and healthy products!

Christine 30th Sep 2019

Awesome

i love this product!so natural and free of chemicals is what i like best!But it looks so great and feels so good on!thanks for a wonderful clean product!

Lisa Ryan 29th Sep 2019

Love!

This is a great eyeliner. Pretty colors, goes on easily, and lasts! ❤

Gail 10th Sep 2019

It's not made of plastic!

I've been trying to eliminate items made of plastic from my life. A wooden pencil eye liner is a good option and the liner stays on most of or all of the day. Hoping Honeybee can find a non-plastic cover for the end of the pencil.

Lisa Henderson 14th Jul 2019

Eyeliner

Best eyeliner. Smooth and creamy, no tugging, stays put all day. Never use any other. Passion is my favorite.

vikiwilson@cfl.rr.com 16th Apr 2019

Eyeliner

The eyeliner glides on eyelid. Does not pull your eyelid skin. Love the color passion. Makes my green eyes look good.

14th Apr 2019

Best eyeliner pencil

I have other eyeliners of similar ingredients and quality this one is my go to every time!

Mary 11th Apr 2019

No staying power

I absolutely love the color Passion, on me it's a dark brown with a hint of purple so it looks mahogany next to my brown eyes. Unfortunately the pencil is just so soft and my eyelids slightly oily and the combination means this pencil sticks around for about an hour before totally smudging below my eyes or disappearing completely. Even putting a base and powder on before the pencil and going over it with a similarly colored eyeshadow only gives it another hour or so on my eyes. It's disappointing because I love this color so much!

Kathy S. 10th Apr 2019

As good as promised

I have never been a fan of liquid eyeliner but that seems to be the trend. So finding a pencil that was smooth enough not to tough on your eye but had the control and sophisticated look of pencil was like a hit the jackpot. Love this eyeliner.

Nicole 10th Apr 2019

Love it!

This is the only eyeliner I will buy! I have it in Envy and Jet Set and both glide on smoothly and have lovely color. I can't wait to try other colors.

Carol K 8th Apr 2019

Awesome

I love, love, love these eyeliners! I've always had a problem finding an eyeliner that doesn't pull. This glides on so smoothly! You have a customer for life!! Oh, and the blue really makes my blue eyes POP! :>)

Lisa Ryan 1st Apr 2019

Effortless is right!

These liners are great, and come in many colors. The color goes on smooth, and blends very well.

Vicky Heeley 25th Mar 2019

The Best of the Best!

After many years of using these wonderful pencils, I still Love them and wouldn't use any others.

elisa 9th Mar 2019

My favorite eyeliner!

Currently my favorite eyeliner! I got it in the purple (passion) color and also the green ( envy). Both colors make my green eyes pop. I occasionally use in my waterline and have no irritation as I do with many other eyeliners. I plan on getting more colors soon!

BabsMuse 6th Mar 2019

Best natural eyeliner on the market!

I've tried numerous natural eyeliners at all price points, and this is by far the best. I love the color passion, a dark purple, which is the perfect color to bring out my green eyes. Please keep making this product. It's outstanding!

soccerkids3@yahoo.com 6th Mar 2019

Liner

I love this product ! I’ve been using for about a year . I first purchased it at boscov’s dept. store. And I actually only use it for my eye brows not as an eye liner !

4th Jan 2019

Smoking Gun Eyeliner

I love the eyeliner I have belgian chocolate and jet set, so I thought I'd try the smoking gun color. The color is beautiful glides on easily and stays on all day. I only give it 3 stars because I just can't get past the sparkle, why they feel the need to put sparkle in it is beyond me. If it didn't have the sparkle in it I'd give 5 stars.

Meg Shea 19th Dec 2018

Sorry, the color runs

I don't know if it's me or the product, but the color runs. I have a hard time finding eye liner that doesn't run, but I didn't find what I need here.

ROCHELLE 7th Dec 2018

Glides on

I love how it glides on!

Gail Sadowski 7th Dec 2018

Wonderful Eyeliner

I love this eyeliner. I have been looking for a pencil that goes on easy and lasts. I found it!! Yay! And no chemicals!

Deb M. 4th Dec 2018

The best!

Goes on smooth and I'm very happy with the ingredients of this eyeliner. It does not irritate my eyes like other store bought eyeliners do. It doesn't last long so I do need to reapply it, but there are no eyeliners that last long anyway. I love it.

13th Nov 2018

So Easy to Apply

I'm very happy with these eyeliners as they truly do go on smoothly with no tugging. It's easy to remove at the end of the day, which I really like. I hope they come out with more colors, like a brighter blue (such as cobalt), because I'd never buy another brand if they did. Highly, highly recommend this product.

137bdg@comcast.net 12th Nov 2018

Not what I expected

Color dry,tugs on eyelid. Lighter color than expected

Lucretia McFaul 8th Oct 2018

Best eyeliner ever

Love this stuff. Covers better than other natural eyeliners and does not irritate my eyes.

Debbie Kalinowski 16th Aug 2018

Good Eyeliner

I truly like this eyeliner. It does exactly what it advertises itself to do: Long wearing, doesn't tug or pull at the eye area,fluid application. I wear the shade Belgian Chocolate. I use this as an eyebrow pencil too and received several compliments. However if you want to soften the line you draw by smudging it, you have to be careful because it is easy to remove. In other words,it doesn't lend itself to smudging well which is why I hesitated giving it five stars. Other than that, it's a very good eyeliner. Comfortable wear too.

Judith Brighton 15th Aug 2018

Eye pencil

Love the color, lovely consistency for application, but it moves around. Maybe it will be better in cooler weather? It was all over my face, and I'd only tight-lined with it!

Patience Flores 15th Aug 2018

Goes on smooth

For years, I tried every brand name eyeliner out there...they ALL irritated my eyes by the end of the day, smudged, or were too solid to apply evenly. The 1st time I used Honeybee Gardens, I knew my search for the perfect eyeliner was over!!

Shirley Snowden 29th Jul 2018

The best eyeliner

I love this eyeliner it glides on so easy and you don't have to worry about it having any bad chemicals in the ingredients!

Deborah James 26th Jul 2018

the best

I have tried so many eyeliners...this one is the best!

Janice 2nd May 2018

Great organic eyeliner

This eyeliner is smooth and easy to apply, also easy to remove. It's the only eyeliner I have ever used that doesn't make my eyes itch!

Barbara 28th Mar 2018

Best pencil eyeliner!

I have tried numerous brands and types of all-natural eyeliner at all price points, and keep returning to this one. With green eyes, I've found the plum color to bring out the color. This is not an easy color to find, but this is perfect. This product goes on smoothly and doesn't smear. The consistency is excellent.

S 19th Feb 2018

Best eyeliner ever

I love this eyeliner. I was searching for something safer to use around my eyes bc I do not wash my eyeliner off much and kept getting irritated by big name brands. This eyeliner is safe, goes on smoothly, deep color, and does not wear off. I love it!!

Tonya Cozart 28th Dec 2017

FANTASTIC

I love this eyeliner. I searched many brands to find a good toxic free eyeliner that looked good and worked well. HBG has done it. Glides on, great color, long lasting and does not bleed!

Windsor Winter 5th Dec 2017

Best. Eyeliner. Ever!

I have tried them all: dollar store to dollar store to high end store. You won't find a better pencil eyeliner.

lindec25@gmail.com 1st Dec 2017

Long lasting and pigmented

This is my fav natural eyeliner by far! I have tried several other brands with similar price point to the ones double the price of this, and HoneyBee Garden eyeliner perform better! I was surprised to see my eyeliner lasted till the end of day, well, because I was used to seeing my eyeliner faded and smudged away. Wow! I am so happy to have found this brand!

Sadie 1st Dec 2017

Stays in waterline!

I first bought this in Passion and notices right away it was different than anything I’ve ever used in my waterline/tightline - it actually stays!!! And for the whole day!! I bought it in Jet right away and love it too! Get this!!

1st Dec 2017

Top notch

Effortless application, smooth, great color, true to picrepresentation.ation

29th Nov 2017

Best eyeliner

I use this eyeliner in the plum color. It is a good shape of plum (not too much purple). It goes on well (goes on creamy...doesn't tug) and stays on. Needs to sharpened pretty frequently but does last a long time. My favorite eyeliner out there.

Giulia Cacciatore 20th Nov 2017

So smooth!

Definitely one of the best vegan pencil eyeliners I've tried, especially for the price. It is so smooth, easy to blend, and is really a true Jet Black. Highly recommend!

Amber 16th Oct 2017

Love their eyeliner, color not for me

First off, their eyeliner is my favorite. Easy to apply, looks great, and has safe ingredients. The latest color I tried was Brown Sugar. I have pretty pale skin and the color doesn't show up at all on me at all. That's okay though because I love all my others!

Janell 20th Sep 2017

would definitely buy more colors!

I am medium skin-toned with dark brown eyes so I bought the Belgian Chocolate eye liner. This was my first eyeliner I ever purchased (I never wore eyeliner, but I'm happy I finally tried it!). I am very happy with my purchase and I'm happy that this Honeybee Gardens eye liner was my first eyeliner. It is so easy to apply, the pencil is easy to hold, and the color is great--not too dark (softer than black). I plan to buy more colors like Smoking Gun or Brown Sugar! If you want an "effortless" eye liner, you need to buy this!

Nemysis 17th Sep 2017

Nice application!

I purchased the Jet Set and like the color. I used it on my lower waterline with no irritation (nice!). I do plan on purchasing more colors. :o)

Gretchen 12th Sep 2017

Name says it all

I wanted something that would go on easy and smooth and this product does. It does sharpen nicely also. I have very sensitive eyes and the Belgian Chocolate eyeliner is great. I did notice that it will fade away as the day goes on. But my trick for making it last longer is to use Coco Loco pressed eye shadow over it. It helps with the staying power.

15th Aug 2017

Stays in place all day

I love the eyeliner! Went on smooth & stayed on all day!

lee 15th Aug 2017

creamy liner

I am so impressed with these liners. Easy to apply and blend. Color is rich and stayed put all day! I'm going to buy all of them!

Madison Jarboe 15th Jul 2017

Overall a great product

I got two of the eyeliners with my latest order, Brown Sugar and Blue Jeans. Brown Sugar is amazing as a brow pencil for me, and equally great as a lower-lid liner. I was disappointed in the color of Blue Jeans, however. It goes on navy, but when you go to blend it turns into a bright aqua color. Not a bad color, but when you are wanting a navy liner it's a bit of a problem. Other than that, these liners are great! They stay in place well and are easy to apply.

Lori 6th May 2017

Finally found my eyeliner

I've tried different "natural" eyeliners with less than stellar success. This one actually goes on well and stays on all day. I will be using Honeybee from now on.

24th Apr 2017

Good formula

Love the formula, nice and creamy so it doesn't pull at my eyes. The gray is just gray, not much to say. I'm pleased. The green is nice but you can't tell it's green if you use it as liner like I do. Disappointed in that color but the description is correct. I wish it was more obviously green though - what's the point of making a green shade if you can't tell it's green! So for this shade, I wasted my money.

Christy 20th Apr 2017

Jet Set, baby!

I have allergic reactions to several drugstore products, so I have to be careful what I put on my face. The eyeliner goes on smooth, doesn't pull, and looks great. It does smudge a bit more than I'd like, but I'll deal with it rather than have puffy, itchy eyes for the rest of my life!

Cindy 9th Apr 2017

Perfect eyeliner

I just received this eye liner (Smoking Gun) in the mail. I was worried it would be melted because mail trucks do not have A/C here in Arizona. But it was fine. I love it. The shade (charcoal) is perfect for me. I am fair with blue eyes and I'm 60. I have natural ash blonde hair. It went on so smoothly in a nice fine line. I absolutely love the hint of sparkle. It is a perfect product for me and safe with no animal testing. I definitely will order again.

21st Mar 2017

Lovely eyeliner

Great eyeliner. A little messy in the hand but goes on smooth and has good staying power.

PS 13th Mar 2017

Good natural liner

I have the Jade and Belgian Chocolate. Both are good colors that you can make a thin line or smudge if you want. I've tried other more expensive natural brands and this one works well for me. I have oily lids so I have to wear a primer.

7th Mar 2017

Vivid effortless precise color

I love that this is natural and gluten free! I love that it glides on, is a strong color, and doesn't smudge like crazy! Perfection.

Cheryl 3rd Mar 2017

Eye liner

This is a pretty blue shade. The problem with my eyes is I have a lot of skin under my eyes. So as I smile the liner runs. Maybe others don't have the problem.

21st Feb 2017

Goes on so smooth!

Love this eyeliner! I have been transitioning to natural makeup, however, even if that's not your goal, I would recommend this eyeliner over any other I've used through the years! I originally ordered the Belgian Chocolate and Blue Jeans (and just ordered the Jet Set). Both colors are true. The navy could be a tad darker, but not a deal breaker (I smudge eye shadow along my eyeliner/lashes to get better wear, and that darkens it to the color I like). I have tried some of their other products now as well, and have loved everything I've tried. Get the lip liner too! Go Honeybee Gardens!

Barbara 16th Feb 2017

My search is over!

I have been looking for a purple eyeliner which draws a thin line, is all natural and has saturated color. There are a several options out there, but even one had one factor that didn't quite work. I used another Honeybee Gardens eyeliner a few years ago, but the color wasn't saturated enough. They seemed to have changed their formula and this one is perfect and can be sharpened to a fine point. I just ordered two more. Please keep making this wonderful product! Thank you!!

Pam 11th Feb 2017

Best Eyeliner

This goes on smooth and doesn't wear off throughout the day. I got the Belgian Chocolate. Great color. I will purchase again.

Candy 18th Jan 2017

Easy to apply, great colors!

These apply nicely, Passion is almost a soft brown; Blue Jeans is fun, I have blue eyes and wear navy mascara with it.

Kelly 26th Dec 2016

love it

Goes on smoothly, stays on well!

Jacqueline 26th Dec 2016

Ease of application!

I have gotten these for a few years for myself and my daughters as gifts and we all love them. Ease, color are all great!!

Candace 1st Dec 2016

So easy to apply!

I tired other organic, more expensive eyeliner pencils and this is the best! It stays on all day, no smudging. I have blue eyes, blonde hair and bought Passion. I just ordered Blue Jeans in the December Buzz Box.

17th Nov 2016

Truly Effortless

This is by far the easiest to apply eyeliner pencil I have ever used!

4th Nov 2016

Better than most

This is the only affordable organic eye liner I can find. You MUST set this with a powder or it will transfer However I would rather touch up my eye liner once or twice a day than put harmful chemicals on my face. So yes 4 stars it gets the job done with minimal touching up.

Karen Houlding 19th Sep 2016

Easy to apply

These eye liners are super easy to apply, very creamy and only require a light touch which doesn't damage the delicate eyelid skin. It does last a long time since it only requires a light touch to get color on the eye. Sharpens extremely well with the Honeybee Gardens Dual Sharpener.

Julie 18th Sep 2016

Great quality

This is a tough one - I love how the pencil works - smooth and sharp. What I didn't love, and will probably keep me from using it much at all is that the "hint of sparkle" in the Smoking Gun is full-on glitter in my opinion. Not at all what I hoped for and feel a little dismayed at the loss. Was really looking forward to charcoal grey.

Hannah 1st Sep 2016

Amazing!!

I've been using a "natural" botanical brand of makeup and recently learned just how bad it really is. I was hesitant to switch to something truly natural because I was worried it would wear off quickly or not go on very dark, but it's amazing! It's smooth, it's dark, and it lasts all day!

15th Aug 2016

smooth sailing

Excellent eye liner - goes on very smooth. True to the description.

Leanne Bryan 8th Aug 2016

The Colors look amazing!

I'm not a big fan of eye liner and I've tried some one a few times and never liked it. But I got one in a Buzz Box last month in Envy green and fell in love. I can't wait to try out more of them! I just put it on the top lid and it keeps it natural but with a flair.

bobbi 4th Aug 2016

it's all in the name

Love the easy application and smooth glide of this eyeliner. The name speaks for itself; effortless.

13th Jul 2016

love this eyeliner

I have green eyes and medium blonde hair. Passion is really nice, have gotten it a few times and i love it. I also got envy this order and it is a beautiful elegant dark green. This liner glides on very smoothly. It lasts nicely yet can be rubbed off. All that and it doesn't make my eyes itch. This is the best eyeliner.

Ann 25th May 2016

Love this eyeliner!

Goes on easily and stays on the whole day! I've had trouble with most eyeliners coming off half way through the day, but not with this one. Will be buying lots more.

Yvonne 11th Apr 2016

Gorgeous Green

I have blue green eyes and this is the loveliest shade of green to compliment them. I'd call it emerald green. The liner is so easy to apply on a 60 something year old eye! Very nice! I bought 4 in case they stop making this color!

Gina Bird 30th Mar 2016

Well I have a new favorite eyeliner color from Honeybee!!

When I saw this color while I opened my Buzz Box for march, I opened it and it just brought the green in my eyes out even more. I feet beautiful everyday when I put anything by Honeybee Gardens on my face Envy is the perfect green eyeliner! Sincerely, Gina Bird

Lauren 16th Mar 2016

I love it!

This eyeliner glides on easily and looks great. It is smudge-able for smokey looks. I love the passion color, even though it isn't as purple as I thought it would be.

10th Mar 2016

A beautiful true Smokey Plum

I love this color so much! It goes with everything because It's more neutral and therefore, by being neutral, it goes with every color, I do wear it with blues, purples, gold, even greens. It is also an awesome color for green eyes! Of course I have green eyes and i have 3 favorite eyeliner colors: Passion, Blue Jeans, and Smoking gun.Honeybee eyeliners are so pretty that you can wear them with or with out eye shadows.and just a hint of mascara. Then your favorite blush and lipstick! That's what I do.

Aria 2nd Mar 2016

Amazing!

This is one of the best eyeliners I have ever used! It lasts all day and is very pigmented. It even works great as an eyebrow pencil

Gina Bird 9th Feb 2016

So pretty!

I will bet that there are many out there who think that Blue can only be worn with the "Cool" genre, and that isn't true. I was always told that I couldn't wear blue with my Emerald Green eyes! I have never been known to play by the rules and I can tell that Honeybee Gardens doesn't either! I wear Blue Jeans eyeliner with warm and cool colors. Sometimes I wear cool/neutral/warm together. I get so many compliments on the cosmetics that I wear now. Thank you Honeybee Gardens! Sincerely, Gina Bird

Gina Bird 9th Feb 2016

I ordered Brown Sugar as a neutral Lip Liner

I couldn't make up my mind on which one of the beautiful lip liners would look the best on me, so I decided to try the Brown Sugar eyeliner. It's pretty and even looks great under the Strawberry Champagne Lip balm that I bought this month. It lasts all day and helps to keep on my already long lasting lipsticks and lip gloss I bought this month! It also looks very pretty with the beautiful lip shimmers from January's Buzz Box! Eventually, I will try a couple different lip liners. Sincerely, Gina Bird

19th Jan 2016

Passion for Passion!

This has quickly become my favorite eyeliner! I love the deep purple color, and best of all, it doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes. It glides on easily. I just wish it lasted all day...my bottom line tends to run a little by end of day. Otherwise, I'd say give it a try--I am now using their eye shadow too, and that is fantastic. Finally, an affordable line of naturally good costmetics!

Gina lynn Bird 13th Jan 2016

I looooooove this color!!!!!!

Wow! I never thought that a grey color would look so good on my green eyes! The sparkle in it rocks too. Thank you for making grey not so bland. This color is just down right sexy and my Husband says I really don't nrrd another. Of course there are 2 others that we both like on me but this one stands out!!! Sincerely, Gina Bird Fort Mohave

Lora 5th Jan 2016

Love the sparkle

I just received the smoking gun color and love it. I love the added sparkle it has, that was a pleasant surprise. It glides on so smooth, you dont get that from alot of eye liners now days, some hurt your eyes. This is amazing!!

Mary Pastrana 8th Dec 2015

Not allergies at all

I really stop using eyeliner more than 5 years due to sever allergies. This eyeliner is soft and easy to puf on. No irritation and I like the color. A most have in your collection.

19th Nov 2015

Great Product, Great Price

Finding reasonably priced cosmetics without questionable ingredients is a challenge. That's why I like Honeybee Gardens. This eyeliner wears well all day with only an occasional smudge or flake, and I feel good knowing that I am making healthier choices. I have used these products for a few years, and I keep returning for more! The Brown Sugar color is a little too light for my pale complexion, so I'll stick with the darker brown eyeliner. I'm still happy with my choices.

Carly 8th Nov 2015

Unexpected Glitter

I am very happy with the formula and staying power of the Smoking Gun liner. However, I was expecting a matte gray, and it is gray with a lot of glitter. I'm not sure why it isn't mentioned anywhere that this is a glittery liner. I would not have bought a gray glitter eyeliner, and I would like to know if all of the eyeliners have glitter in them because that will affect my purchases in the future.

2nd Nov 2015

Very Happy

This was my first try with the eye liner. Goes on smooth and lasts. It seems easier to apply then my other brand with all the toxic ingredients. So happy to not have to worry about getting exposure to chemicals if wanting to wear makeup. Will definitely re order.

2nd Nov 2015

Smoking Gun is sparkly!

I love this eyeliner which was part of my first Honeybee Gardens order. The only reason I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 is because it's actually sparkly with glitter in it. If I would have known that, I probably would have ordered a different color. But otherwise I love it!!

Val 1st Nov 2015

Excellent

These liner pencils feature excellent colors and the perfect pencil texture -neither too soft and smudgy, nor too hard and difficult to apply.

5th Oct 2015

Best pencil liner I've tried

The first thing I noticed is how smoothly this eyeliner goes on. It's lovely! It lasts all day without smudging. I would absolutely recommend this.

1st Oct 2015

Best Creamy Eyeliner Pencil I've Ever Tried!

Most eyeliner pencils are hard and tend to hurt my eyes when I apply them but this one is so soft and creamy it's great! Even though it's soft it doesn't smudge which another bonus. LOVE LOVE LOVE this product!

lauren 20th Aug 2015

love it!

Glides on smooth and doesn't make my eyes itchy. I'm in love!

8th Jul 2015

Eyeliner is safe to use and works wonderfully!

I love this eyeliner. It goes on smooth, doesn't pull. Plus it is safe to use and reasonably priced. Can't ask for more!

4th May 2015

awesome

most eye products cause my eyes to itch and it rub them off trying to get relief, but this product is truely not causing me any discomfort.

2nd May 2015

Wonderful product

I use the Jet Set eyeliner & mascara. I've had a hard time finding natural, cruelty free cosmetics, but these 2 products have worked wonderfully. I just received my second set and I'm still loving them. It's a bonus that they arrived quickly and are starting to branch out into more stores so you don't have to order half-way through using the products or trying to find something to use in the meantime. I really love the products I've used. I did get some samples with my first order and couldn't decide whether I cared for them or not but can't say for sure how I feel about them without actually ordering the full products first. I will definitely continue to buy from this company.

Gianna 26th Mar 2015

The Best Organic Eyeliner!

Everytime I order the JETSET eyeliner, it is shipped and I receive it within 2-3 days! My eyes are very sensitive and this eyeliner has never given me any infections or problems. They eyeliner is so smooth & the perfect texture. It stays on forever. I would never betray my honeybee eyeliner!

Natalie 2nd Mar 2015

Great product

First time trying the Honey Bee Gardens products and I am very impressed with their quality. A nice soft eyeliner, that applies easily and is a rich color (black).

JS 24th Feb 2015

Awesome colour, texture and does not aggravate my skin

I'm really happy with this eye liner. I have very sensitive skin, but this is the first eye liner that does not flare up my eczema. The texture too is great - it's not so dry and hard that you have to press hard to get any effect. Love it!

14th Feb 2015

As good as my old eye liner

It goes on super smoothly, and is a great dark color. It lasts all day. Very happy with my purchase and to have found a safer alternative to my old eye liner!

Tammy 19th Nov 2014

This is a wonderful line of products!

I absolutely love this line and strongly recommend it to everyone! Especially those who are concerned with chemicals in beauty products. Excellent!

D'Shay 4th Nov 2014

Definitely recommend

Perfect natural essential to add to your makeup bag. All the qualities of any other great liner without the harmful ingredients and inflated price tag. I have this pencil in black.

GG 9th Oct 2014

luv

glides on, great color, stays on long if I pat a little shadow over, doesn't itch!!! the only downer is the plastic cap splits REPLY: We will be happy to send you a new cap if yours breaks. Just send us an email.

7th Oct 2014

Envy is Pretty

Great color that is not too bright. The eye liners from Honeybee Gardens are great. My only complaint is that after a while, the clear plastic caps split and no longer protect the eyeliner tip. It would be great if the cap was sturdier and lasted as long as the eyeliner.

Michele 30th Sep 2014

Good basic eyeliner

Aside from being all natural and HBG having quick customer service, this eyeliner is a good basic to have. My fave colors are blue jeans and jet black.

Kat 7th Aug 2014

Pulls my skin, doesn't last.

This does not stay put on my 56-year-old skin. It pulls and tugs at my delicate eye area. Just does not work for me. Nice colors however!

Beth 31st Jul 2014

Long lasting high quality product

I am so thrilled with this eye liner. I was searching for a natural product and this product gives me peace of mind. I highly recommend it.

Lauren Rusch 27th May 2014

nice

I love that this doesn't irritate my eyes. I'm not sold on the pencil yet, it doesn't tug on my eyelids but still doesn't give me the smooth smudgy look of my previous eyeliner pens. I'm giving it the benefit of the doubt til I can work with it more. i love how soft it is. The staying power is ok, not great, at the end of the workday i have to clean up a few dark streaks under my eyes. I think i would pair this with a primer and powder for a longer lasting look.

S.C 21st Mar 2014

Love it!

Goes on nicely, and stays on nicely. Best part for me is that I can wear it without allergic skin reactions. No other cosmetic products were working for me, until I found H.B Gardens! (Not even the products that are supposedly made for sensitive skin) So, I am thrilled to be able to wear makeup, again!